By Katie Nelson
A tutorial on the Immigrant rights movement
Migrant Rights are Human Rights
1 – Learn how migration is a human experience.
2 – Explore how US policies violate immigrant rights.
3 – Make some change!
Figure 1: Bracero workers crossing the US-Mexico border, 1956, Leonard Nadel, Smithsonian Institution
Let’s begin with a few definitions.
Refers to human movement from one socially and geographically bound place to another.
This is the preferred term in social sciences (because it does not dehumanize people) to refer to people who have crossed a national boundary or reside in a country without formal authorization to do so. In the context of US law, it is also more accurate than “illegal” as residing without documents is not a criminal offense, but a jurisdictional matter decided through a complex legal process.
A Tale of Two Feet
So let’s start at the beginning. As far back as we can go…200,000 years ago. When humans emerged as a species in Africa we were fully bipedal. We walked on two feet! This allowed us to carry things, including babies and tools. We were/are efficient long distance runners. We burned fewer calories running and walking that many other early humans (like Neanderthals). We were constantly on the move.
The climate in early human history was volatile. But we were smart and able to travel long distances and adapt to different environments. We had to move because our food sources changed. We were nearly hairless and could sweat to regulate our body temperature. This allowed us to travel for long distances in the hot sun to avoid predators and get food (something most large land mammals could not do).
Figure 2: Humans are efficient long distance runners. Early humans likely used endurance hunting. We were constantly on the move.
Migration: A Human Adaptive Strategy
Starting about 10,000 years ago the first humans (in the Middle East) began to develop agriculture. This led to a radical change in life in which people spent more time in permanent settlements. However, even then people were always on the move. People moved for marriage, to avoid conflict, to be closer to agricultural plots, as a result of climate change and for many other reasons. Migration has not only been the norm for all of human history, it has been what made us human! It is a central human adaptive strategy.
There is extensive archaeological evidence that humans migrated frequently. Much of this migration was adaptive, meaning it helped people better cope with the environmental (and other) pressures in their lives. In the ancient world, Greek colonization and Roman expansion depended on migration. The Indus, Inca and Zhou empires were also associated with massive migration as were the Vikings and Crusaders.
Migration in North America
Archaeological and genetic evidence tells us that the first migrants to come to North American were from central Asia. Starting in the 1600s, European immigrants came en masse to make North American their home. Nearly 90% of the original indigenous inhabitants were killed from disease and ethnic cleansing.
In sum, the history of human movement shows us that:
- Migration is part of what makes us human; if people were not prone to migrate, we would not exist.
- Migration helps people adapt to changes. If people cannot survive in their immediate environment, they migrate to some place better. It’s human nature!
- Migration is frequent and common in history and today.
- With the exception of forced migration and slavery, human migration is mostly adaptive.
It’s fair to say that immigrants MADE America. However, with the exception of white, male, protestant, wealthy men, most immigrant groups in the US have experienced discrimination. This is especially true for each new successive wave of immigrants. Immigrants viewed as culturally, linguistically, ethnically, religiously, politically and “racially” inferior were especially targeted.
US Immigration policy has tended to be discriminatory and based on economic pressures. When the US has needed cheap labor, policies were expanded to increase migration. For instance, between 1800 – 1850 the newly expanded country needed European settlers and Chinese laborers, who were recruited extensively. Starting in World War Two, the US again needed laborers and recruited Mexican farm laborers under the Bracero Program.
However, when the economy has contracted, immigrants were targeted, intensely discriminated against and even deported. The Chinese Exclusion Act (1882), The Immigration Act of 1917 (implemented a literacy requirement), The Emergency Quota Act of 1921 are some examples. The Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952 allowed the United States to exclude immigration from “ideologically undesirable countries.”
Figure 5: Upon entry to the US, bracero workers were fumigated with DDT, a toxic chemical now banned. More than 4.5 million Mexican citizens were recruited and legally hired for work in the US under the Bracero Program.
In 1986 Congress passed the Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA), which attempted to address undocumented immigration through amnesty programs for undocumented immigrants, as well as criminalizing the hiring of undocumented immigrants as workers and instituting the I-9 form for all employees. This led to a gradual trend in increased militarization of the US Mexico border. However, employers were tacitly permitted to hire undocumented workers as they were not penalized, but the workers could easily be deported.
Figure 6: Families Belong Together Rally In Washington DC, 2018.
Unjust, racist and discriminatory immigration laws hurt many people, not just immigrants themselves. Deportations separate families, leaving US citizen children without their parents. Family and local economies are also destroyed by deportations. Undocumented immigrants do not come to the US because they are bad people, they simply don’t have the money or opportunity to immigrate through official channels. They are doing what comes natural to humans, migrating to someplace better to survive.
Immigrants are people, just like anyone. They should be treated with the same human dignity and respect as citizens. The US Immigration Detention System is deeply flawed and the Trump Administration routinely violates basic human rights with impunity. Immigrants in detention are especially vulnerable, especially during the COVID-19 crisis.
Video 2: High School Students in Los Angeles protesting dehumanizing rhetoric.
The U.S. Immigration Detention System is Broken
Click each link to learn more!
- Immigrants frequently die in detention centers because of government negligence
- Immigration detention is designed by the Trump Administration intentionally to separate families.
- Conditions in immigration detention centers are unsafe and inhumane.
- Sexual abuse and assault is rampant in detention centers.
- The detention system violates due process rights.
- Private prison companies profit from immigration detention.
Video 3: Music video No Human is Illegal by Bynd Chikko
So What is the Solution?
We have to decriminalize immigration
We need to reverse unjust laws
We need society to recognize importance and dignity of immigrants
Video 4: Maria Hinojosa quotes Elie Wiesel and explains why no human being is illegal
What Can I Do?
Learn more by reading the ACLU’s “Fact-Checking Family Separation.”
Sign a petition and tell Congress to stop spending our tax dollars to enable mass incarceration and deportation!
Sign up for People Power to find out about actions you can take to fight family separation and learn about other critical civil liberties issues. You can find events in your area posted to the People Power map.
Find other volunteer opportunities in your area that match your skills:
Together We Can Make Change!
Figure 1: Braceros Crossing Bridge by Leonard Nadel: Smithsonian Institution
Figure 3: Reconstruction of Asian hunters migrating across Beiring Straight during the first ice age. DEA Picture Library/De Agostini/Getty Images
Figure 4: Map of Human Migrations by 180 is released as CC BY-SA 3.0.
Figure 5: Fumigating Braceros by Leonard Nadel, 1956: National Museum of American History.
Figure 6: Families Belong Together Rally In Washington DC Sponsored By MoveOn, National Domestic Workers Alliance, And Hundreds Of Allies by Photo by Ilya S. Savenok/Getty Images for MoveOn.org
Video 1: Map Shows How Humans Migrated Across The Globe by Science Insider
Video 2: No Human Being Was Born Illegal by Not in Our Town.
Video 3: No Human is Illegal by Ft. Bynd Chikko
Video 4: Maria Hinojosa quotes Elie Wiesel and explains why no human being is illegal provided by Define American